Best Pizza Restaurants in Sarasota, Florida
Looking for the cleanest pizza restaurants in Sarasota? We ranked all 18 Sarasota pizza spots by their InspectFL Health Score — a 0–100 metric calculated from public Florida DBPR inspection data. The top 18 are below. RISE PIES HANDCRAFTED PIZZA leads the list with a score of 100 — an A grade based on consistently clean inspections. 11 of the top 18 carry an A grade; the rest sit in B-grade territory or lower. Average health score across this list: 95.1.
Showing top 18 of 18 pizza restaurants in Sarasota
RISE PIES HANDCRAFTED PIZZA
140 UNIVERSITY TOWN CENTER DR, SUITE 150, SARASOTA
100/100
TRALIA PIZZA
6566 GATEWAY AVE, SARASOTA
100/100
CASANTICA RISTORANTE
1213 N PALM AVE, SARASOTA
98/100
ELENI'S PIZZA WORKS
6711 15 ST E, SARASOTA
97/100
PIZZA CHEF
5501 FRUITVILLE ROAD, SARASOTA
97/100
JOEY D'S CHICAGO STYLE EATERY AND PIZZERIA
381 KENNY DR, SARASOTA
97/100
BRIO
190 UNIVERSITY TOWN CENTER DR, SARASOTA
96/100
HUNGRY HOWIE'S 3251
3251 17 ST UNIT #90, SARASOTA
96/100
THE OLIVE GARDEN 1114
4900 S TAMIAMI TRL, SARASOTA
96/100
PATELLINI'S PIZZA
1429 MAIN ST, SARASOTA
96/100
IL PANIFICIO
1703 MAIN ST, SARASOTA
95/100
PI PIZZA 3.14 ON MAIN LLC
1507 MAIN ST., SARASOTA
94/100
PAPA JOHN'S #643
3416 CLARK RD, SARASOTA
93/100
RICOS PIZZA
322 JOHN RINGLING BLVD, SARASOTA
92/100
IL PANIFICIO'S SIESTA
215 AVENIDA MADERA, SARASOTA
92/100
VENEZIA
373 ST ARMANDS CIR, SARASOTA
91.3/100
SALUTE RISTORANTE
23 N LEMON AVE, SARASOTA
91/100
NONNO UMBERTO ITALIAN SEAFOOD AND STEAKHOUSE
22 S BLVD OF THE PRESIDENTS, SARASOTA
90/100
