Best Italian Restaurants in Saint Augustine, Florida
Looking for the cleanest italian restaurants in Saint Augustine? We ranked all 48 Saint Augustine italian spots by their InspectFL Health Score — a 0–100 metric calculated from public Florida DBPR inspection data. The top 20 are below. 7 of them earned a perfect 100, including BLACKFLY THE RESTAURANT. Average health score across this list: 99.5.
Showing top 20 of 48 italian restaurants in Saint Augustine
BLACKFLY THE RESTAURANT
410 ANASTASIA BLVD., SAINT AUGUSTINE
100/100
PAPA JOHN'S
4255 US 1 S STE 15-16, SAINT AUGUSTINE
100/100
BELLATRINO PIZZERIA
59 WEST AVENUE, SAINT AUGUSTINE
100/100
DELLA TORRE’S ITALIAN DELI
180 REGISTRY BLVD STE 102, SAINT AUGUSTINE
100/100
ONLY PIZZA LLC
950 FL 206, SAINT AUGUSTINE
100/100
NYC MEATBALLS & PIZZERIA STA
2730 101-103, SAINT AUGUSTINE
100/100
THUNDER J'S PIZZERIA
3915 A1A S STE 105, SAINT AUGUSTINE
100/100
NONNA'S TRATTORIA
2 AVILES ST, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.8/100
MARCOS PIZZA
74 CAPULET DRIVE SUITE 207, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.8/100
PIZZA HUT 4283
156 SR 312, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.5/100
PIZZA HUT #4282
525 SR 16 #116, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.5/100
MARCO'S PIZZA #8614
230 PLAZA BLVD STE 6, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.5/100
ANTONIOS NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA ON THE BEACH
378 A1A BEACH BLVD, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.5/100
BRONX HOUSE PIZZA
389 PASEO REYES DR STE 205, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.3/100
PAPA JOHN'S PIZZA
10440 US 1 N #122, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.3/100
SALS CUCINA TASTE OF ITALY
145 BRONZ GLOW WAY, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.3/100
DOMINO'S #3179
3501 N PONCE DE LEON BLVD E, SAINT AUGUSTINE
99.1/100
AMICI ITALIAN RESTAURANT
1915 A1A S STE B, SAINT AUGUSTINE
98.9/100
DERITA ITALIAN DELI
155 HAMPTON PT DR STE 4, SAINT AUGUSTINE
98.8/100
DOMINO'S #5105
3570 US 1 S, SAINT AUGUSTINE
98.4/100
