Best Seafood Restaurants in Sarasota, Florida
Looking for the cleanest seafood restaurants in Sarasota? We ranked all 14 Sarasota seafood spots by their InspectFL Health Score — a 0–100 metric calculated from public Florida DBPR inspection data. The top 14 are below. SIESTA KEY OYSTER BAR leads the list with a score of 97 — an A grade based on consistently clean inspections. 5 of the top 14 carry an A grade; the rest sit in B-grade territory or lower. Average health score across this list: 92.5.
Showing top 14 of 14 seafood restaurants in Sarasota
SIESTA KEY OYSTER BAR
5238 OCEAN BLVD, SARASOTA
97/100
OLD SALTY DOG (THE)
5023 OCEAN BLVD, SARASOTA
96.5/100
LOBSTER POT SEAFOOD RESTAURANT
5157 OCEAN BLVD, SARASOTA
96/100
CRAB & FIN
420 ST ARMANDS CIR, SARASOTA
95/100
CAPT CURTS CRAB & OYSTER BAR
1200 OLD STICKNEY PT RD, SARASOTA
95/100
JUICY CRAB SEAFOOD
560 N WASHINGTON BLVD UNIT E, SARASOTA
94/100
OLD SALTY DOG CITY ISL (THE)
1601 KEN THOMPSON PKWY, SARASOTA
93/100
BIG WATER FISH MARKET
6639 MIDNIGHT PASS RD, SARASOTA
93/100
MARINA JACK PATIO
2 MARINA PLAZA, SARASOTA
92.3/100
LEFTY'S OYSTER & SEAFOOD BAR
428 N LEMON AVE, SARASOTA
91/100
OWEN'S FISH CAMP
516 BURNS LN, SARASOTA
91/100
SPEARFISH GRILL @ SIESTA KEY MARINA
1265 OLD STICKNEY POINT RD, SARASOTA
90/100
KACEY'S SEAFOOD & MORE
4904 FRUITVILLE RD, SARASOTA
88/100
CRABBERS
4195 N TAMIAMI TRL, SARASOTA
83/100
