Key West, Florida
Monroe County · 381 restaurants
At the end of the Overseas Highway, Key West packs over 370 restaurants onto a tiny island just 2 miles wide and 4 miles long. Duval Street is the main artery of tourist dining — from rowdy bars to upscale seafood houses — while the quieter streets of Old Town hide some of the best meals in the Florida Keys. Fresh-caught fish, Key lime pie, and a Caribbean-influenced culinary identity make Key West's food scene as unique as the island itself.
Data on this page
InspectFL turns public DBPR inspection records into city-level score trends, grade breakdowns, and restaurant history so this page is useful for comparison, not just a list of names.
About Dining in Key West
Of Key West's 381 graded restaurants, 62.5% earned an A grade — roughly in line with statewide averages. Currently, 2.1% of restaurants hold a failing F grade, representing 8 establishments with significant health violations. The average InspectFL Health Score across Key West is 93.3 out of 100, based on 613 inspections on record.
What Inspectors Look For
Florida DBPR inspectors evaluate restaurants on food temperature control, employee hygiene, pest activity, and equipment cleanliness. Violations are categorized as critical (immediate health risk), major (significant concern), or minor (procedural issue). Learn more about how grades work.
Explore More
- Monroe County restaurants — see all cities in this county
- Statewide rankings — compare cities and counties across Florida
- InspectFL Blog — analysis, trends, and deep dives on Florida restaurant inspections
Highest Rated in Key West
Lowest Rated in Key West
Restaurants
Page 4 of 16YELLOWFIN
5950 PENINSULAR AVE
CUBAN COFFEE QUEEN DOWNTOWN
5 KEY LIME SQ
DORADA KEY WEST
1500 REYNOLDS ST
EL MOLCAJETE RESTAURANT
1500 BERTHA ST
FLAGLERS (MAIN KITCHEN)
1500 REYNOLDS ST
ISLAND TINGZ BAR AND GRILL
1105 SIMONTON ST
JAMACIAN PUSH CART
410 WALL ST
LITTLE WHITEHOUSE SUBS
218 WHITEHEAD ST #1
LOLITA'S
245 FRONT ST
NEW YORK PASTA GARDEN
1075 DUVAL C1
SALUTE
1000 ATLANTIC BLVD
SV ARGO NAVIS
0 DUVAL SLIP 6
THIRSTY MERMAID
521 FLEMING STREET
B.O.'S FISH WAGON
801 CAROLINE ST
CAFE SOLE
1029 SOUTHARD ST
MANGOES
700 DUVAL ST
SOAP DEL DIA INC
525 DUVAL STREET
SQUARE GROUPER BAR AND GRILL
920 CAROLINE ST
BLACKFIN BISTRO
918 DUVAL STREET
CAROLINES CAFE
310 DUVAL ST
FOGARTY'S RESTAURANT BAR & BAK
227 DUVAL ST
HARBOR VIEW CAFE/ONE DUVAL
1 DUVAL ST
HARD ROCK CAFE
313 DUVAL ST
IRISH KEVIN'S BAR
211C DUVAL ST
LA PINCHA KEY WEST
101 FITZPATRICK ST