Saint Augustine, Florida
St. Johns County · 538 restaurants
As the oldest continuously occupied European settlement in the United States, St. Augustine brings 450 years of history to its 450+ restaurant scene. The cobblestoned St. George Street in the historic district draws tourists to its collection of restaurants, while the San Marco Avenue corridor and Anastasia Island offer more locally oriented dining. The city's food culture blends Southern, Spanish, and Minorcan influences — including the famous datil pepper that flavors many local dishes.
Data on this page
InspectFL turns public DBPR inspection records into city-level score trends, grade breakdowns, and restaurant history so this page is useful for comparison, not just a list of names.
How to use this city page
Start with the citywide grade mix, then use filters to narrow by category, grade, or inspection dates before opening the full restaurant record.
What the citywide data means
Saint Augustine has a heavier concentration of failing restaurants than you’d want, which makes recent inspection history and dispositions especially important.
Best supporting links
How to read a restaurant page, editorial standards, and corrections.
About Dining in Saint Augustine
Of Saint Augustine's 537 graded restaurants, 43.2% earned an A grade — below the statewide average, suggesting room for improvement in local food safety. Currently, 13.4% of restaurants hold a failing F grade, representing 72 establishments with significant health violations. The average InspectFL Health Score across Saint Augustine is 87.3 out of 100, based on 2,198 inspections on record.
What Inspectors Look For
Florida DBPR inspectors evaluate restaurants on food temperature control, employee hygiene, pest activity, and equipment cleanliness. Violations are categorized as critical (immediate health risk), major (significant concern), or minor (procedural issue). Learn more about how grades work.
Explore More
- St. Johns County restaurants — see all cities in this county
- City rankings — compare this city with others across Florida
- Editorial standards — understand what is official vs. InspectFL analysis
- InspectFL Blog — analysis, trends, and deep dives on Florida restaurant inspections
Highest Rated in Saint Augustine
Lowest Rated in Saint Augustine
Restaurants
Page 8 of 22PAPA JOHN'S PIZZA
105 MURABELLA PKWY #4
CASA MAYA
22 HYPOLITA ST
DELLA TORRE’S ITALIAN DELI
180 REGISTRY BLVD STE 102
FLORIDA CRACKER CAFE
81B ST GEORGE STREET
HOLIDAY INN EXPRESS VILANO
140 VILANO ROAD
HOTBOX
50 FULLERWOOD DR
MEEHAN'S IRISH PUB
20 AVENIDA MENENDEZ
ROSATI'S PIZZA
520 W TWINCOURT TRL STE 6
ST AUGUSTINE HOTEL & SUITES
475 COMMERCE LAKE DR
ST MARYS SEAFOOD & MORE
705 HORTON'S TRACE
ABOUT TIME CREAMERY
2900 STATE RD 16W
LA AMAPOLA CAFE
4010 US 1 STE 103
MARSH CREEK COUNTRY CLUB
169 MARSHSIDE DR
SMOKING D' S 2
5495 1 ST
FALAFEL QUEENS
1080 PONCE DE LEON
ANDAMAN ASIAN CUISINE
4010 US 1 S #121
CASA DE VINO 57
57 TREASURY ST
CHIANTI ROOM
60 CHARLOTTE ST
PROHIBITION KITCHEN
119 ST GEORGE ST
SNACK SHACK LLC
100 ST GEORGE ST STE A
QUALITY INN ST. AUGUSTINE HISTORIC DISTRICT
2800 N PONCE DE LEON BLVD
LA QUINTA INN AND SUITES
250 PRIME OUTLET BLVD
SURFSIDE KITCHEN
85 AVA WAY SUITE 105
BEACHES AT VILANO BEACH
254 VILANO RD
ST GEORGE TAVERN
116 ST GEORGE ST A
Important context for city pages
City pages are comparison tools built from public Florida DBPR inspection data. They help surface local patterns quickly, but they are not official government rankings and they should not replace reading the individual restaurant page before making a decision.